Comparison of book trojan war to movie troy

Comparison of Troy and Iliad

A second viewing of this film revealed a heightened contrast between foreground and background. Because the film eschews the presence and intervention of gods that is so prevalent in the Iliad, Paris is made to survive the encounter by means of Hector killing Menelaus, purely because Paris is "my brother!

Just at this moment, Paris arrives at court as peace envoy from Troy. At the end of the movie, when Troy was on fire, Achilles tried to find his loved one and Paris killed him with his bow and arrow.

In the foreground, however, the story is played out in directorial choices that distort the work of Homer almost beyond recognition. It also provides part of the backbone to the plot within both texts which involve Achilles battle for glory which will last forever. Happily, I found that he and I are pretty much in agreement and I will leave it to Roger to discuss the foreground activities of the actors.

Ulysses has been gone from Troy for several years, but the goddess Calypso caught him in her web and would not let him go. He also shows that even heroes have villainous qualities. They are feeling threatened by the powerful Greeks to the West.

Great armies take to the field. The first nine years of war pass quickly across the screen and finally the story begins to approximate the part that Homer wrote. There is a model as well of a Greek warship, and a suggestion that the film would need a thousand of these ships in full-scale.

Achilles is used as a secondary character here, a blunt force warrior.

Troy vs. the Trojan War

They choose Paris, a prince of Troy then living incognito as a shepherd. Both of them begin with the passionate love affair between Helen of Sparta and Paris, Prince of Troy. It is the legend of the Trojan War. The Greeks set sail with a mighty armada and the Trojans prepare for war. Of course the epic siege is a big part of the story, but the myriad of interpersonal stories is the real driving force of this movie.

The loves of the movie stars are banal, but the panoramas of the Trojan War are spectacular. The film too shows the ships in such rows, but fails to realise that having the sun rise over them, up from the Aegean Sea, means it would be raising from the West.

Agamemnon and Menelaus, looking like pewter soldiers, arrive on the island to summon Odysseus to the war against the Trojans. She puts Odysseus under a seductive spell and five years pass before he comes to his senses.

While the film retains the enmity between Achilles and Agamemnon, and the causes of the Trojan war, it departs significantly in the way that it aligns Achilles and Hector with a more modern, melodramatic "Hollywood" attitude toward honor and honorable conduct. Homer also tries to convey that all warriors have a choice between a life of war and a life of peace.

Like many who were not educated at school, I had little knowledge of Homer or of the importance of this war as a milestone in history. This is the only one of the films covered in this post that encompasses the entire span of the war, from the Judgment of Paris to the fall of Troy, and the death of Agamemnon.

They open the gates and lead the Greek army which then burns the city to the ground. In the war, Achilles was the main representative for Greece or rather, for himself and Hector for the civilians of Troy.

The backgrounds are marvelous, offering spectacular views of the landscapes and seascapes between the palaces at Mycenae and Troy. When Tyndareus dies, Menelaus becomes king. After his death, some sources say she was exiled to the island of Rhodes, where a vengeful war widow had her hanged.

They fall in love. This ends the first installment. However, in the movie Troy the Gods are barely even mentioned, and are only mentioned when referred to when signs are received.

The gods, he says, are no longer needed. Whatever the reason, the lack of the gods in Troy left the film with a sour taste in my mouth as i was interested to see how they would portray the gods and how big of a row they would have.

Agamemnon is inspired to attack Troy by a dream sent by the gods, who want to bring his army misery for taking Briseis away from Achilles. Still, it cannot be overlooked that this story of the homeward journey is driven primarily by mythical fictions.

Despite this, she has had a premonition that he will die if he goes to war. Since the cavalier excavations of Heinrich Schliemann in the late s, there has been a growing sense that there is a geography and a historical timeline to the events of the Trojan War.

The head designer makes it clear that they were interested in historical inspiration only so far as it contributed to the epic concept of the film.Within the Iliad, the war upon Troy lasted for 10, presumably very long years before the wooden horse ploy was developed and put into play, this is very different from what the film Troy depicts, which only has the war last for 17 days before the walls of Troy are breached from within inside.4/4(1).

Dicuss similarities and differences between Homer’s Iliad and the movie Troy Essay Sample. The ancient legend of Troy, recorded in Homer’s epic poem “The Iliad” Oxford (trans. Robert Fitzgerald University Press ) has been retold in many other forms, the most recent being the blockbuster film “Troy” (, Wolfgang Peterson).

The two films, dedicated to the charms of Helen of Troy as the cause of the Trojan War, set the stage for the ancient viewpoint on the conflict. Both of them begin with the passionate love affair between Helen of Sparta and Paris, Prince of Troy.

Movies about the Trojan War

The adaptaters of The Lord of the Rings put a lot of effort to include everyone's favourite bits from the book. How well does the movie Troy do by this criterion?.

First off, let me try to remember the story of the Trojan War. (The following is not a spoiler for the movie.

Follow or Like to continue viewing these differences

Sep 20,  · The story of the Trojan War—the Bronze Age conflict between the kingdoms of Troy and Mycenaean Greece–straddles the history and mythology of. Comparison of Iliad Book and Troy Film. Comparison Paper on the Book Iliad and Film Troy On the Plot The plot of the book and the film has a very big difference especially on its coverage and focus.

Comparison of book trojan war to movie troy
Rated 5/5 based on 49 review